The steam-barge SELAH CHAMBERLAIN was in collision with the steamer JOHN PRIDGEON. The CHAMBERLAIN sunk 6 miles E. of Sheboygan, Wisc. Five lives lost
Friday, October 15, 1886
. . . . .
The SELAH CHAMBERLAIN was in collision with a N.Y.C. railway boat, the JOHN PRIDGEON and went to the bottom 6 miles east of Sheboygan on Lake Michigan. 5 were lost. The CHAMBERLAIN was bound from Milwaukee to Escanaba.
Port Huron Daily Times
Friday, October 15, 1886
. . . . .
October 13, 1886 while the steamer SELAH CHAMBERLAIN was towing the FAYETTE BROWN. during thick and foggy weather off Sheboygan on Lake Michigan a single blast of a whistle was heard. The steamer blew one blast in exchange and then three to indicate she had a tow. She was ported, but the lights of the other steamer were seen on her port bow when the CHAMBERLAIN's wheel was put hard aport, and she blew a single blast. The other steamer the JOHN PRIDGEON JR., now two blasts, then went into the CHAMBERLAIN's port bow, sinking her at once. M.A. Bradley owned the CHAMBERLAIN, and the PRIDGEON was owned by the Ogdensburg, Lake Champlain railway. The case went from U S. district to U.S. circuit court, being last heard before Associate Justice Harlan in Chicago. Harvey D. Goulder and Schuyler & Kremer represented Mr. Bradley and H. C. Wisner was for the defendants. The former received the following from Washington, signed by the associate justice :
The conclusions of law are as follows
"First that the CHAMBERLAIN is not chargeable with all fault in respect of the collision.
"Second, that the master of the PRIDGEON having the CHAMBERLAIN on the starboard side of his vessel, and being, therefore, obliged to keep out of the way of the CHAMBERLAIN, if it could be done, did what under the circumstances he ought not to have done, viz : he starboarded when he should have ported his wheel and failed to do what under the circumstances he should have done viz: He went ahead after discovering the lights of the CHAMBERLAIN, when he should have reversed until he ascertained the location of such vessel and the direction in which it was moving.
"Third, if the master of the PRIDGEON had ported instead of starboarding his wheel, or, if, immediately on discovering the lights of the CHAMBERLAIN, he had stopped and reversed the collision in question would mot have occurred.
"It is, therefore, considered that the law is for the libelants. Let a decree in their behalf be prepared and submitted to the court for approval."
The case, which involves $60,000 may go to the supreme court, but there it will only be a question of law.
September 25, 1890
Pridgeon-Chamberlain Case Settled at $44,000.
The Vermont Central Railway Company has paid the Bradley estate $44,000 in settlement of the loss of the steamer SELAH CHAMBERLAIN, which was sunk off Sheboygan, Wis., in October, 1886, through collision in a fog with the steamer JOHN PRIDGEON, JR. The PRIDGEON was owned by John Pridgeon of Detroit but was under lease to the Vermont Central and was running in its Chicago-Ogdensburg line when the collision occurred. The CHAMBERLAIN was in command of Capt. Greenley when sunk. Five of the crew were lost by the capsizing of one of the small boats after the accident. Capt. George Stone spent some time later in an attempt to raise the boat but the water in which she went down was too deep for successful wrecking work. Harvey D. Goulder of Cleveland represented the CHAMBERLAIN and C. E. Kremer of Chicago the PRIDGEON in the legal proceedings that followed the collision. Judge Blodgett in the United States district court at Chicago gave the CHAMBERLAIN a full decree, mainly on evidence showing that the PRIDGEON was running at a high rate of speed in a fog, and the decision was sustained by the Unit States circuit court. It was thought that the case would be be carried to the supreme court, but the appointment of Judge Blodgett to the new appelate court probably hastened the settlement, as decisions of the new court are final in admiralty cases. Recourse to the privilege of limiting liability on the part of the representatives of the Pridgeon caused a settlement at less than the value of the CHAMBERLAIN. This is the only case in the history of the lakes, and the second one in the United States, where a steamer got a full decree in an accident happening in a fog.
October 22, 1891
Steam screw JOHN PRIDGEON Jr. U. S. No. 75756. Of 1,211.88 tons gross; 1,037.11 tons net. Built Detroit, Mich., 1875. Home port, Detroit, Mich. 221.5 x 36.3 x 14.0 Of 600 Nominal horse-power.
Merchant Vessel List, U. S., 1891