WAS THE WILBUR RACING
The collision in the Grosse Point cut by which the steel consort MARTHA was sunk by the E. P. WILBUR so as to half block the channel, as described in the Free Press yesterday morning, is the strongest kind of argument for the government regulation of the entire channel, just as the St. Clair channel is ruled. The disaster, which means a loss of perhaps $30,000, might have been entirely avoided had the limit of speed through the channel been placed by government at, say, eight miles an hour, and all boats compelled to observe it.
Capt. Hutton, who was compelled to put his steamer, the A. A. PARKER, and consort ashore to avoid running into the wrecked boats, reported privately to his owners that the Lehigh steamer WILBUR, which sunk the Minnesota barge MARTHA, and the Western liner TROY had but a few minutes before the crash passed him at a high rate of speed, all bound up, and that he considered such action a shame. The fact that the forward end of the strong steel barge MARTHA is completely demolished for thirty feet back from the stem bears out Capt. Hutton's statement. Such radical injury could only have been caused by a propeller going at a high rate of speed. The MARIPOSA, towing the MARTHA, both deep laden with ore, down bound, could not have been going at better than seven miles an hour. Owing to the fact that their keels were within a couple of feet of the bottom. The WILBUR, on the other hand, was only partly loaded, drawing but eight feet forward, and in fine trim for racing. All of the foregoing evidence indicates that the TROY and WILBUR were racing, undoubtedly to be the first to reach the canal. As the disaster occurred in the Detroit local steamboat inspection district, the inspectors will probably know within a few weeks whether or not a race was on. Following their findings the inevitable lawsuit will also disclose the fact of a race, if there really was one.
The chief officers of the MARTHA and WILBUR, following the lake custom, are keeping close mouths, reserving their statements for the attorney's of their lines. The members of the WILBUR's crew say the MARIPOSA blew one whistle to pass to starboard, the WILBUR answered it and all went well until the WILBUR neared the MARIPOSA, when the latter sheered right towards the WILBUR, and the distance was too short to avoid a collision. This may and may not be true. But little dependence is to be placed in the offhand statements of a lot of deckhands, watchmen and wheelsmen.
In noting a protest to the underwriters yesterday Capt. Hutton, of the A. A. PARKER, states that he was bound up, about 400 feet behind the WILBUR, when he heard the crash, and saw the WILBUR and MARTHA swing across the channel ahead. He quickly ordered his wheel hard-a-port, and blew one whistle. The WILBUR answered with an alarm whistle. Capt. Hutton, with lightning quickness, had already chosen the better course. He had to decide between running into the wrecks ahead or into the mud on the channel-bank, and to the latter he went. The PARKER buried deep into the mud, and her consort, B. W. PARKER, followed her. Capt. Lohr, of the latter, also had a hard-a-port wheel, and she ran up on the starboard side of the steamer and into the mud, though not so hard. The tugs SAGINAW and WALES spent all of yesterday lightering the coal cargoes of the two.
Diver John Quinn examined the MARTHA yesterday morning and returned in the afternoon with the statement that he never saw a bow so badly smashed on any boat. He drew a diagram which indicates the MARTHA presented her port bow to the WILBUR's stem. The hole is very wide and goes in so deeply as to demolish the forecastle and break up the collision bulkhead. Three deckhands were asleep in a small room on the starboard side of the forecastle, and the mass of steel had just reached the door of their room when it lost its impact and they were enabled to open it and crawl out, and in time to escape the inrushing waters.
The MARTHA now lies on the west bank of the channel, her once shapely bow now transformed into a mass of curled and twisted steel beams and frames and plates, with a towing machine and cable, anchors and chain, steam-capstan, etc., all piled in atop of it as if to add to the general confusion. She blocks the channel about one-half, but as she will be well lighted at night, passing vessels should have no trouble getting by in both directions.
Detroit Free Press
October 28, 1900
. . . . .
THE WILBUR IS IN DRYDOCK -- DAMAGED ABOUT 410,000.
Further examination does not show the damage to the MARTHA to be less serious than reported. Her forward end must be entirely renewed from the stem clear to a point fifteen feet abaft the collision bulkhead. The cost of repairing her will, at a rough guess, be easily $50,000, and it is possible this amount will be exceeded. Whether the whole or any part of this shall be borne by the Minnesota Line depends on whether it can be proved that the WILBUR and TROY were racing. If they were, the bills will be paid by the WILBUR alone or divided between her and the TROY.
As for the WILBUR, she was pretty hard hit as well, and will have to spend several weeks in the big dock at the foot of Orleans Street. Sunday her cargo was transferred to the TUSCARORA, a sister ship, and into the big dock went the collider. Yesterday morning she was surveyed there by Parry Jones, great lakes representative for the London Lloyds, who holds the insurance on her. He was assisted by Robert Logan, of Cleveland. They found that twenty-six plates must be removed. Some can be rerolled and replaced, others are fit for scrap iron only. Besides several frames and parts of the keel are demolished. The surveyors approximate her damages at $10,000.
Detroit Free Press
October 31, 1900
. . . . .
A SMASH-UP ON LAKE ST. CLAIR.
Of all the smash-up that have ever resulted from collision on the great lakes that of the steel barge MARTHA, shown in the accompanying illustration, is the worst. The MARTHA was bound down Lake St. Clair at Grosse point at 10 o'clock at night, Oct. 26, loaded with iron ore, in tow of the steamer MARIPOSA when she was struck and sunk in the shallow water of that vicinity by the steamer E.P. WILBUR, bound up with a cargo of general merchandise. The force of collision was so great that ore from the hold of the barge was thrown up on deck. It is useless to discuss the cause of the collision as there are no definite statements from the crews of either vessel. On the part of the sunken vessel it is claimed that the WILBUR was running at a very high rate of speed, racing with the steamer TROY. It is certainly strange that the WILBUR escaped without great injury. A large number of plates in her bow are of course damaged, and repairs may require an expenditure of probably $10,000 but aside from damage to forward plating, the bow of the WILBUR is not at all like that of a ship that had suffered such great shock of collision. The WILBUR is owned by the Lehigh Valley Transportation Co. of Buffalo and the MARTHA by the Minnesota Steamship Co. of Cleveland. The latter company has a large fleet of steel vessels that have not been insured this year and unfortunately their losses have been very heavy. The photograph from which the illustration was made was furnished to the Review by Charles T Benham of Detroit.
November 1, 1900
. . . . .
The U. S. Court of Appeals at Cincinnati has handed down a degree in the celebrated TROY - WILBUR - MARTHA collision case, holding the TROY and WILBUR wholly responsible and partially reversing the decision of Judge Swan of Detroit. The accident occurred on the night of October 26, 1900, in Lake St. Clair. The owners of the MARTHA, which was sunk, may recover $43,000 damages.
Buffalo Evening News
Saturday, March 12, 1904
Schooner barge MARTHA.* U. S. No.92697. Of 2815 gross tons. Built Chicago, Ill.,1896. 352.0 x 44.2 x 22.4.
* Renamed FLORENCE - U. S. -
FLORENCE J. - Canada - 1938
MAUREEN H. - Canada - 1938 [C 170554 ]
OWENDOC - Canada - 1949
Herman Runge List