Maritime History of the Great Lakes

J. W. Hall Scrapbook, 1876-, p. 19

The following text may have been generated by Optical Character Recognition, with varying degrees of accuracy. Reader beware!

PA yeSTeTGay. During last night the schooner Belle 1 Hanscomb, wheat-laden, from Detroit for Buf- ; falo. went ashore one mile west of this place, and lies in a bad position. The crow is safe. ESCANABA. , Spof]"al Telegram to The Inter Ocean. Escanaba, Mich., Oct. 17.— Okl vessel captains pay that the pale of yesterday was the most severe ever experienced on Lake Michigan. Eaqfy in the morning the schooner Evening Star struck [ near Lighthouse Point, drifted alon« to within 200 yards of the Tilden House, and now lies high | and dry on the beach. A long channel will have L to be dredged in order to get her into deep water. , She was not damaged, l-'.o other mishaps have I i been reported, except loss of spars and rigging. A sailor named Wm. Ross, of Port Rowan, was washed overboard from the schooner Louisa, off Port Colborne. . The steamer Flora has been seized at Detroit to satisfy a claim for fuel, filed bv the Brazil and Chicago Coal Company, amounting to $1,370.05. The steamer was promptly bonded. COLLISION. PBOPELLER CANISTEO SUNK, Bpecial Telegram to The Inter Cveau. Cheboygan, Mich., Oct. 14. A collision occurred at S o'clock this morning -"at Waugo-shancs Light between an unknown schooner and the propellor Canisteo, ia which the tatter sunk in seventeen feet of water inside the pier. The vessel crossed the steamer's bow and was the mizzen rigging. The night was clear, but the vessel's lights were ob-fcoo. late to know how she was as the red and green was ¦ at interval previous to thn collision. The schooner was bound up. The propeller was bound down with general cargo. The vessel is white, with a lead-eolored bottom, and passed up when it'ascerfcained that the crew had landed. The vessel's side was badly ripped up. Tn.g Winslow will reader assistance with pumps, and - "-¦-¦*- ' here bo-night. alloup Bho.ala, Lake Ontario, at 3 o'clock! Wednesday morning, and at last accounts had! four feet o\ water in her hold. She has a cargoJ of whps**u, the insurance on which amo""y*/icj $20,700. The Wilder is a cannier, and vj$ S;ick^ in 1 V L Biie is owned bv B. Everlei::h,\yhetherf ¦ ior, and was valued at $3,500. sured is not known. hour be- While jibing the Wilder about an Ja ikaon fore she wont' ashore, Captain Chariot .¦ by the was struck on the head over the left e;~ow un-main boom pen I was carried bt.. ed for conscious, in which condition ho remain two hours or longer. He will recover. Steamer K. T. D."Peyton, of Philadelphia."" ' John Osborn, wife, and three children, of Chicago. Keal McGillvray, of St. Joseph, Mich. Mrs. DeCondres, of Evanston, 111., who had [been to Grand Haven on a charitable mission 1/ Mrs. Vandecar, of Chicago, was the wife of a machinist employed in the shops of the Pittsburg and Fort Wayne Railroad, and living at 3638 South LaSalle street. The body which was washed ashore at Holland yesterday morning is supposed to be Mrs. Vandecar. The following list COMPRISES ALL THE OEFICEBS s can be ascertained at the present ghter leave FS^OSMG THE DEAD (?> _ —-— Waiting for the Bodies of 1he Alpena's Passengers to Wash Ashore. Anxious Friends and Eelatives of louring Beach the Lost Scouring the Entire The Shore Covered with Scattered. Fragments of the Wreck. 1_ Canadian Propeller Europe Kissing1, ' and It Is Believed She B.as Gone Down. A Crew of Twentj -five anil a Large Number of Passengers on Board the Vessel. ¦------------------»¦----------------- Her Consort the Keelson Gone to Pieces at the Manitous with Other Craft, of Grand of Grand as far j writing; Captain Nelson W. Napier, of St. Joseph,' Mich., who leaves a wife reported to be crazed with grief, several sons, who a^c well known tugmen in Chicago, and two minor children First Officer, J. H. Kelly. Second Officer, Atvm Patten. First Engineer, Robert Johnson, Haven. Second Engineer, Robert Patton Haven. , Stewar* William Shepherd, whose brother Harry was drowned at Muskegon about two years ago, while acting as steward of the Alpena. Clerk, Arthur Haynes. Porter, Thomas Lynch, of Grand Rapids, who leaves a mother and sister at that place, and a brother, who is employed at Jerry Monroe's, in this city. The young man, who was a general favorite, had $2,000 coming to him, and is said to have expressed great fears of venturing on the last trip of the Alpena, owing to having been through a storm aoout a week ago. Fireman, Harry Falls. James Bayue, of Grand Rapids. Fred Perry, of Chicago, who was acting as cabin-boy for pleasure and experience. This makes a total of eleven men. The usual complement of officers and hands is thirty, of whom eight or ten are deck hands. The latter cnange so often that it is next to impossible to i tell who were on board. The same m&ay be said j of the steward's crew. Allowing thirty as the officers and crew, this | would make fifty-six souls who went down on the i Alpena. The Goodrich Line office was visited yesterday | by numbers of people, but no intelligence could be given them regarding the Alpena further than I has^ been already published. Nothing was re-| eeived from Superintendent Butlin all day. In I the evening the following dispatch was recived: Grand Hayek, Mich., Oct.-JO, 1880. , A. E. Goodrich : Have found trunk, with insurance policies and letters marked B. F. Sweet, Braidwood, 111., and some marked Mrs. Plienie Sweet. W. F. Sweet. The trunk was found about eight miles this side of Grand Haven. The dispatch would indicate that there was at least one. and perhaps two, passengers not in- oluded '""'^^liA^ffuiurfiiLijMiafr FREIGHTS. Charters reported on 'Change yesterday were ts follows; To Buffalo—Schrs Thomas P. ffibel-lon and Thomas Parsons, corn at 4%c. To Eric -Prop "Wissahickou, corn on through rate;. To Collingwood—Schr M dland Rover, corm on brough rate. In thf afternoon the schooner Frank I). Bavrkcr vas taken for flaxseed to Buffalo at 5]2c: scihr F. kl. Knapp. wheat to Buffalo at 5c; schr Riiver-iide, corn to Kingston at a rate not learned. Lumber freights were unaltered. THE CANISTEO DISASTER THE LATEST PABTICULAES. The sunken propelfer Canisteo lies in seven-teen feet of water. From Chicago her cargo consists of 15,000 bushels of corn, and sundries, and she also probably took on flour at Milwaukee. There can be but very little salvage on the oarffo. Hull and cargo are insured, and tugs are at the scene of the disaster. The Canisteo is owned by the Union Steamboat Company. She is an old craft, and has no great valuation, but, as indicated by her cargo, was stil 1 in the grain ' trade. Several vessels are mentioned as the one : that collided with her. ' 'Special';.' . :¦.<,!¦ fnter Oo san. MACKINAW City, Mich.-, Ocd. 15.— Your correspondent was up to the Canisteo this afternoon, and found her in bad condition. She will probably be a total wreck. She lays on a reef, and both ends are afloat so she works with the sea. Her bulwarks are stove in on both sides* and her dock-load has all washed overboard. It has blown so that the tug has been unable to work at her. ^C Further Details of the Disasters! Upon the Great Lakes—The Si at est. WRECK OE THE GBENADA. SEVEEAL OF THE CHEW LOST. Special Telegram to The Inter Ocean. Muskegon, Mich., Oct. 17.—The schooner Grenada, of Muskegon, left here Monday might v. Lto 250 m lumber for Chicago. She was dismasted in to-day's gale, and drifted on the breach about one mile north of Muskegon pie dark the vessel is reported going to pieces. The mate and one man were washed overboard with ?j part of the deck-load wheu the vessel struck,, and succeeded in reaching the shore. The cook was {washed overboard scon alter, and drowenect. two others are supposed 'to have been <! , ls the captain and one man were all that mould >e seen aboard tne vessel at dark. ¦91 THE ISTJRKAY AND THE CANISTEO, A LAWSUIT IX PHOSPECT. A private dispatch from Buffalo is as follows: "Buffalo, N. Y., Oct. 25.—The companies insuring the hull and cargo of the lost propeller Canisteo propose to attempt to hold the soho>oner George Murray for the loss. They say that good lawyers are of the opinion that the Murray can bo held, the master of the Canisteo and his officers and crew swearing that the Murray aasnsed t.ho ™iv:oir**i A lawsuit seems inevitable." MORE DISASTERS. MORE BKAVE LIFE-SAVERS LOST. Special Telegram to The Inter Ocean. Rogebs City, Mich., Oct, 20.—The sailboat belonging!^ the lite-saving station at Forty Mile Point, -with Captain Jos. Sawyer, of Detroit; Keeper George Feaben, and Joseph Valentine, coming from the station to this place, capsized in a squall at 10 a. m., when about ten miles off here. Captain Sawyer and Keeper Feaben were drowned. Valentine was rescued by a small boat from here. ___.¦ THE ILL-FATED ALPENA. Considerable pains have been taken to present a complete list of the passengers, officers, and hands on the Alpena, and the net result is presented below. As stated heretofore, no duplicate list of the passengers was kept, and the register of the boat went down with her. Several names are omitted from the previous lists given, it being discovered that they were not on board the Alpena. John Bowen, an- officer reported lost, called at Tee INTEB Ocean office last evening to show that he was alive and well. Mr. Ryder, of Syracuse, reported to be lost, took passage on the De Pere instead of the Alpena, and is consequently still in the land of the living. Mr. vV. C. Pettibone, supposed to have been on the Alpena, took a train to Muskegon. It is possible that others of the reported lost are alive and well. Mrs, George McConnell, whose name is sometimes given as Maggie Mack, is believed bv the officers of the Goodrich line to be visiting friends in Michigan. Her name was given as among those onboard, and a trunk bearing her name has floated ashore *at Holland, but she quit the service of the vessel about ten days ago, and it is possible left her trunk on the Alpena till she took up other quarters- Her name is therefore not given in the list below. As far as can be learned, there were TWENTY-SIX PASSENGERS ON THE ALPENA, including the children. Owing to the fact that. just at this time, the railroad companies running through Michigan are giving extremely low rates, to induce people to come to the Exposition, the passenger traflic on the Goodrich steamers leaving the east shore has been extremely light, the steamboat line rei using to lower their rates. "While the boats leaving Chicago have been crowded, those corning this way have carried very few travelers. The number given—twenty-six—may therefore be regarded as complete. The passenger list is as follows: Montgomery Crossrnan, of Grand Haven. Mr. Crossman was the second son of one of the oldest settlers of Marengo, Calhoun County, Mich. and formerly resided in Marshall, that State. Al-, though less than 30 years of age he was well known throughout the State by his many mechanical inventions, conspicuous among which •were his improvements in wind-mills. He was foreman of the Stevens Manufacturing Company. He leaves a wife in a delicate contlition and a giri 3 years old. Sidney Thomas, Esq., of Chicago, is a cousin of his. W. S. Benham and wife, Grand Haven. Mr. Bcnham was editor of the Grand Haven Herald, and came from Iowa. He leaves two children— a son (a young man) and a girl of 10. Mrs. B. F. Cartes, the wife of a prominent lawyer of Grand Haven. Heber Squier, Jr., of Grand Haven. He leaves a wife and three young daughters, whom he was going to Chicago to visit. Mrs. Newton Bradley and her daughters, Miss Lou Bradley and Miss Kate Bradley, OF SANTA FE, NEW MEXICO. Fred Spaeth, of Grand Rapids. G. Hotfinger, of Grand Rapids. C. Kusterer, of Grand Rapids. H. Landreth, of Mpskegon, a brother of George Hubbard, of Grand Haven. Mrs. S. B. Cole, of Ottawa, 111. II. T. Locke, agent of HiU Bros., New York. Rev. Farrell Hart and wife, White Pigeon, Michigan. ------Boblinsky, a dealer in old iron, Chicago. Harrv L. St. Clair, of Lawndalp. Til Captain A. E. Goodrich was asked to give his theory of THE FATE OF THE ALPENA, and replied: "I thought first that, she might have broken her engines and been lost in that way. lam satisfied that she did not. She had very powerful engines. Vessels saw her up to the middle of Saturday, and her engines were working then. One vessel reports that she saw the Alpena listed down so that one wheel was out of the water and the other in the trough of the sea, and her engines were then at work. My own opinion is this: Captain Napier was a man full of courage. There was no such thing as cowardice about him. He had that bulldog, hang-to activeness that would not give up as long as there was a righting chance. The Alpena n was last seen about thirty miles off Chicago. In-J stead of squaring off for Milwaukee, as he migti have done had he commenced in time, he fough the storm until the sea got so big than when sh< dropped into the trough of the sea her freighl shitted to the leeward, pitching one wheel out oj the water, and lie was not able to right her. Sin probably remained in that position until th« sea knocked her to pieces, which was probably good many hours. I think she rode out the] storm. She probably did not go to pieces until the wind shifted to the northwest. That was Sunday night, I don't think she went to pieces] until that time because of the stuff going ashorei at Holland. If she had broke up previously, when ttie wind was from the southwest, portions of the wreck would have drifted in the neighborhood of the Sauble. But the stuff struck the beach so much further south it would look as if the wind had shifted to the northwest before she went to pieces. I think she lasted a long time after she dropped into the trough of the sea She must have gone to pieces somewhere between Racine and the oast shore, some time Saturday night or early Sunday morning. I don't think any small boat could have lived in that storm., I suppose all must have perished. If my theory is correct the bodies of the passengers and crew will probably come ashore between Grand Haven] and Holland. We have men there patrolling thei beach, and as soon as a body is found we will be. [informed of the fact by telegraph "" It is a significant fact that the Mary Groh went£ through the storm and was saved by having A MAST AND SAIL Had the Alpena had a sail and mast, she, too,j| might have been lifted out of the trough of their [ sea, in which she was shaken to pieces. It is the! opinion of many lake men that all passeogcr steamers should be thus provided in case of emergency. Captain Goodrich said that the Alpena had, i: officers and crew, twenty-five men, as follows Captain, two mates, two wheelsmen, two loo" out men, six deck hands, two engineers, two firi [men, clerk, steward, four cabin boys, two cook the collision. From all that can be learned in Chicagro, it seems that the Canisteo was wholly to blaime for the collision, and it has been understood thait he owners of the Murray would send a bill forr the damage to the Murray to the owners of the (Canisteo—-The Union Steamboat Company. The Canisteo was valued at abou; $46,0009, and her cargo at about $25,000, making $U5,,000. Tue value of the Murray is about $45,,000. Good lawyers in Chicago, who were seen last night by the marine reporter of THE Iinteb Ocean—three of our best admiralty lawy/ers— say that under the circumstances, as show-in by Captain Hurlbut's protest, the Canisteo stsands •her own loss, and, in justice, should also pa;y for the damage to the Murray. THE SUNKEN BAEG-E SCOTT. LATEST 'CONCERNING ITE11. The barge Thos. A. Scott, sunk in Mihvauj kee Bay, lies in about thirty-two feet o: water, and an attempt may be made to res cue her. The hull and cargo, of corn arc fully covered by insurance. The propeller Avon, which collided with the Sc< caused her to sink, arrived in Chicago on Saturday morning, She bears no evidence of the collision. It will he remembered that several years ago, when the Scott was a propeller, it was alleged that she collided with the brig Robert Burns, which went down with all hands. ) THE TRADER LOST, WITH ALL HANDS. The inquiries of the Goodrich Company iin re gard to the Alpena have developed the sad fact that the steambarge Trader is lost, and thait all hands probably perished. The barge City of Grand Haven, which put back to Grand Haven last evening, reported passing through the, wreckage of the Trader on Friday mornimg off] Grand River, and the officers of the Grand ISaven (according to a late private dispatch) are off the impression that there are no survivors. The Trader's route was between Chicago and Mtuske-gon, she being engaged in the lumber ttrade. Captain Frank Brown was master, and the icrew numbered, in all, ten men. She" measured! 150J tons, and was built at Marine City by P. Priice in 1865. Her class was B 2, and her value :aboutj $6,000. S. A, Brown, of Marine City, wais the] owner. ______ FBEIG-KT& All vessels offering on Saturday for grain were taken. The charters were: To Buffalo —Prop Fountain City, corn, at 7c; schrs M". W. Page, J. I. Case, Ellen Spry, George Murray, David Vance, Red Wing, Saveland, Angus Smith, Red, White and Blue, corn, at 7c; steambarge William Edwards, corn, at 7c; prop Portage, oats, at 5c; schr City of Green Bay, flaxseed, on p. t. To Erie—Prop Juniata, corn, on through rate. Lumber freights are firm and unchanged. _______._. . Teepin_ Captain Goodrich said that he still considered! impracticable. There are generally three gang! ways leading to a steamer, and people kep coming in and out clear up to the last minute departure, so that until the steamer hai shoved off from the shore the officers didn' generally know who their passengers were. gateway such as is used at railroad depots I impracticable, because a steamer lands at differ ent piaces along a dock, instead of one giver point. No register is kept upon any river, lake. or sound steamers or vessels in the country, au. this fact alone speaks as to its practicability. Captain Goodrich has Buttered intense anxiet; over the fate of his ill-starred steamer, and m one has been more deeply pained than he at tin calamity. He did not wish to be understood af saying that the public did not care who wer( lost. What he gaid was. that the sympathy o WRECK OE THE GRABTADA. STATEMENT OP A SimVIVOft. SpeciaJ Teleeram to The Inter Ocean. Muskegon, Mich., Oct. 18.—William Biissell, mate, and Angus Linklater, brother of the> captain of the Granada, were the only survivoors of he wreck. Linklater's report is as follows:: "The vessel left for Chicago Friday night under a strong breeze. Shortly after the [steering apparatus gave way and we were left tto the mercy of the waves. The storm grew morre and more severe and each moment we expected to be thrown into eternity. Saturday' noon the steward and a sailor died from exposure, amd I myself prayed to God that I nnight be struck dead with one of the masts. At noon Sunday we saw land, and at once "began to make rafts. Soon after I discovered a sailor being erustued to nieces where the vessel had parted, for slue was fast going to pieces. He cried, "For God's- sake, move me," I did so, and wrapped him ia canvas. The captain and I made a. raft and sttarted for shore. Soon after it parted and the caiptain went down. He came up and I seized hirni, but he was again washed off. I never saw him mgain. In pulling him up I crushed my hand atgainst the lumber. I hung on till washed off,, then swam, and was picked up near shore and kcindly cared for. Wm. Bissell started for the nmore, was several times washed from the raf;t, but fought bravely. He could hardly walk whien he got there. His first words were, "For God's; sake, get a line to them poor fellows." The other sailors perished. There is not a vestige of the schooner left" SEASIAK" DROWNED. A dispatch from Toledo, dated Saturdays says: "The schooner Oneonta, of Chicago, arrived from Buffalo to-day, reports having ; lost a man overboard on Thursday morning i about 1:30 o'clock, twenty miles from Port I Burwell, Lake Erie. The man was aloft at :; the foremast head shifting sail, and, missing ] his foothold fell into the Jake. The wind was blowing a six to eight knot breeze, and it was very dark. A boat crew was at once sent out from tho Oneonta to endeavor to ;. rescue the sailor, but on account of the j darkness accomplished nothing, and in the end the crew of the small boat lost sight et' the Oneonta. They were picked up by another vessel. The Oneonta remained by ¦ until daviight, but seeing no signs of the -missing sailor proceeded to this port. During heavy weather on Saturday last the scnooner Annie Craig, engaged in loading timbers on the Lake Erie shore, lost one anchor and was obliged to slip tne other to avoid going on the beach. The tug McArtnur made a search for the ancnors, but broke her windlass, and had to go to Detroit for repairs. The man lost overboard from the schooner ¦, Oneonta, when off Port Burwell, was a resident \ of Buffalo, named Robert Clark, about 20 years , of age. He is well spoken of by Captain Everett \ and his shipmates, and was generally respected J by ail who knew him. The Oneonta's^boat's crew, which missed the vessel " ~~ ""' '" THE HOLMES AND THE ALPENA. WHAT CAPTAIN OLSON SAYS. _________^^^^^^^^^^ , Ghand Haven, Mich., Oct. 21.—The Ibody the public was excited by the magnitude of ; of John Locke, of New York City, agentt for disaster, though tiiey did not care for individual Hills Brothers, of that place,"1 has just c:ome names, personal interests being swallowed tip n in here. His watch stopped at 10:50 a. m., the extent of a given disaster. While he had re- at which time the Alpena must have ftoun-ceived a number of telegrams, they were read: Sered, as Captain Olson, of the schoione-ail «TrtT™™fl T^r. t>™^ mTTT, «m™,»™« Holmes, states he was in company withi thr umiES BEGAF.DING the steamer, _ g^toa between 10 and 11 o'clock. She wae and not as to who were on board, and from this blowing her whistle for assistance and shiows fact he was disposed to think that the cry ovei r«-"r-o —— -—;j--~ the need of duplicate passenger lists was greatlj^g signals of distress.—bpecial to The Jnter exaggerated. ^^^^ A story was current yesterday that the Alpena took fire before she went to pieces. The rumor was doubtless based upon the facts contained in the following letter; "Waukegan, 111., Oct. 20. "Captain A. E. Goodrich. . Sin: There was a large fire on the lake off here last Saturday night, seen by the night police and Captain Minsky's wife, between 12 and 3 o'clock. Yours, F M. Pouter, "Night Police." Ocean. William H. Kae, one of the crew of thie propeller Aiesseuger, was lost overboard late Monday nnrnt, while tne Messenger was on met' vva> to Chicago from St. Joseph. The deceased was wateinnan. He resided at Bt. Joseph, years of age, and single. , was 25 isaeu ww »<;oo^ ..nile searching \ lor Clark, were picked up by the schooner William Home, on board which Captain Lverett found them. FBEIGHTS. THE SITUATION. Grain charters reported on Saturday were as follows: To Buffalo—Steam barge W. H. Grat-wick (Friday evening), wheat at 734c; prop Oswegatchie, wheat at 734c; prop Arabia, corn at 7c; schr Negaunee, corn at 7c; steambarge Northerner, corn at 7c. To Erie—Prop Philadelphia, corn on through rate. To Collingwood— Prop Northern Queen, corn on through rate. The going rate on corn to Buffalo was 7c. In the evening several vessels not yet unloaded were stated to have been chartered at the same . figure. Lumber freights ruled as follows: Muskegon to Chicago......................82.37*2 Menominee to Chicago.................... 2.7S Straits to Chicago........................ - 2.75 Manistee to Chicago....................*... 2. "5 Frankfort to Chicago...................... 2.87*2 Ludington to Chicago.................... 2.50 White Lake to Chicago.................... 2.50 Cargoes were somewhat scarce. ANOTHER BODY. The body of a man with an Alcena life-preserver on was found at Port bheldon Saturday morning and taken to Grand Haven. He had on a double-breasted blue flannel overshirt and coarse, heavy shoes; no pantaloons or Has a short, light beard, was about six fett in height, and wore a porous plaster over each lung. The body was very much decomposed and dis-| figured. _ Captain Drake, Superintendent of tho Union Drydock and Shipyards of Buffalo, mourns the loss of a devoted wife, who was buried from her home on Friday. Mrs. Drake was the daughter of Captain Ludlow, and a favorite niece of Captain Fred Miller, of the propeller Arctic. Sue was a woman of remarkable sweetness of disposition, and the mother of six children. She was about 35 years of ago. Captain Drake has the sympathy of a very largo circle of sailor as well as family friends.

Powered by / Alimenté par VITA Toolkit
Privacy Policy